Why Is My Leg Press So Much Stronger Than My Squat? Find Out Here
If you’ve ever found yourself wondering why you can lift significantly more weight on the leg press machine than you can during a squat, you’re not alone. This is a common occurrence that many weightlifters and gym-goers experience, and it can be puzzling and frustrating.
After all, the squat is considered one of the most fundamental and effective exercises for building lower body strength and muscle mass. So, why is it that your leg press performance outstrips your squatting ability?
In this blog, we’ll explore some of the possible reasons why your leg press might be stronger than your squat, and offer some tips and strategies for addressing this imbalance and improving your squatting strength. Whether you’re a seasoned lifter or a beginner, understanding the mechanics behind this issue can help you make better progress toward your strength and fitness goals.
Why Is My Leg Press So Much Stronger Than My Squat?
The primary reason why your leg press might be stronger than your squat is that the mechanics of the exercise are different. For example, squats require more stability and engage more muscles in the upper body during the motion. The angle of the exercise also gives a mechanical advantage to the leg press machine, allowing you to lift heavier weights with less effort. In addition, squats require more focus on form and control in order to be completed with proper execution, whereas the leg press is relatively simple. As a result, you can use heavier weights with less risk of injury while performing the leg press. Moreover, since you’re not lifting your entire body weight plus extra weight during the leg press, this reduces CNS fatigue and you don’t have to contend with a heavy barbell as in a squat. Finally, the leg press requires less range of motion than a squat does, which means you use fewer muscles and burn less energy during the exercise too.
Let’s now look in more detail at how you can bridge the gap between your leg press and squatting strength. Here are some practical tips you can use to overcome this imbalance…
1. Squats are harder
Squats are a compound exercise that requires a significant amount of strength, balance, and coordination to execute properly. Unlike the leg press machine, which primarily isolates the leg muscles and allows for a more controlled and stable movement, squats require you to engage multiple muscle groups, including your quads, glutes, hamstrings, core, and even your back and shoulders, in order to perform the movement. This complexity makes squats inherently more difficult than leg press for several reasons.
While the leg press can be a valuable exercise for building lower body strength, it simply cannot match the complexity and difficulty of squats. Incorporating squats into your workout routine can help you build overall strength, improve your balance and coordination, and even improve your performance in other exercises.
2. Provides more stability
The leg press machine provides a level of stability and control that is unmatched by free-weight exercises like squats. This is due to several factors that make the leg press a popular choice for individuals looking to build lower body strength and muscle mass.
The leg press machine is designed to provide a stable platform for your feet and back. The footplate is typically large and can be adjusted to accommodate different foot positions, allowing you to target different areas of your legs. Additionally, the backrest provides support and ensures that your spine remains in a neutral position throughout the exercise.
Secondly, the leg press machine allows you to control the weight and resistance throughout the movement. You can add or remove weight plates to adjust the intensity of the exercise, and you can easily stop or pause the movement at any time if needed. This level of control can help you focus on proper form and prevent injury.
Lastly, the leg press machine eliminates the need for balance and stabilization that is required in exercises like squats. This is particularly beneficial for individuals with weaker stabilizer muscles or those recovering from injury. With leg press, you can isolate and target specific muscle groups without worrying about losing balance or compromising form.
3. The angle of the exercise provides a mechanical advantage
One reason why the leg press machine can allow you to lift more weight than squats is due to the angle of the movement. The leg press machine allows you to push the weight at an angle that is more favourable to the muscles in your legs, providing a mechanical advantage that is not present in squats.
During squats, you are pushing the weight directly against gravity, which requires a higher level of force output from your muscles. In contrast, the leg press machine allows you to push the weight at a more horizontal angle, reducing the amount of force needed to move the weight. This means that you can lift more weight on the leg press machine with less effort than you would during a squat.
Additionally, the angle of the leg press machine can allow you to target different areas of your legs with greater precision. For example, if you place your feet higher on the footplate, you can target your glutes and hamstrings more effectively. Conversely, if you place your feet lower on the footplate, you can target your quads more effectively. This level of specificity is difficult to achieve with squats, which tend to engage all leg muscles equally.
4. Much less upper body engagement
One key difference between the leg press machine and squats is the level of upper body engagement required to perform each exercise. While squats require you to hold a barbell or dumbbells on your shoulders, the leg press machine allows you to focus solely on the lower body muscles without engaging the upper body to the same extent.
During squats, the upper back muscles, core muscles, and shoulder girdle muscles are all engaged to varying degrees in order to maintain proper form and balance. This means that a significant amount of energy and effort is required from the upper body, which can be tiring and may limit the amount of weight you can lift.
It is important to note that neglecting the upper body muscles can result in imbalances and weaknesses that can impact overall strength and performance. Incorporating exercises that target the upper body muscles, such as rows, presses, and pull-ups, can help build a well-rounded and balanced physique.
Related: Why Do Knees Hurt After I Deadlift?
5. Simplicity of exercise
Another advantage of the leg press machine over squats is the simplicity of the exercise. Unlike squats, which require a significant amount of technique and form, the leg press machine is a relatively simple exercise that can be easily learned and performed by beginners.
With the leg press machine, there are fewer variables to consider. You do not need to worry about maintaining proper form or balance, as the machine provides a stable platform that supports your body throughout the exercise. Additionally, the movement pattern is simple and straightforward, involving only the extension of your legs against a weighted resistance.
This simplicity can be particularly beneficial for individuals who are new to strength training or who have limited mobility or experience with free-weight exercises like squats. It allows them to focus solely on building strength and muscle mass in their legs without worrying about the technical details of the exercise.
6. Less CNS fatigue
Central Nervous System (CNS) fatigue is a state of temporary exhaustion of the neural pathways that control muscle contractions. This occurs when the body has been subjected to high-intensity training that demands a lot of neuromuscular activity. Compared to squats, the leg press machine puts less strain on the CNS, allowing for a greater volume of training to be performed without reaching CNS fatigue.
During squats, the CNS is heavily involved in coordinating the movements of the muscles in the lower body. This coordination is necessary for the body to lift heavy weights while maintaining proper form and stability. Because squats are a compound exercise that requires the involvement of multiple muscle groups and neural pathways, they can be particularly demanding on the CNS. As a result, the body may reach a state of CNS fatigue more quickly during squat training sessions.
In contrast, the leg press machine provides a more stable platform for the lower body, requiring less coordination and neuromuscular activity. This means that the CNS is not as heavily involved in the exercise, allowing for a greater volume of training to be performed without reaching CNS fatigue. This can be particularly beneficial for individuals who want to perform higher volumes of lower body training without overloading the CNS.
7. You’re not lifting your body weight plus extra weight
One significant difference between the leg press machine and squats is the amount of weight being lifted. During squats, you must lift not only the weight of the barbell but also the weight of your own body. This means that the amount of weight being lifted is significantly higher than with the leg press machine.
In contrast, the leg press machine only requires you to lift the weight of the load being used. This is because the machine provides a stable platform that supports your body throughout the exercise, and your body weight is not a factor in the resistance being lifted.
The lack of additional body weight in the leg press machine can be advantageous for individuals who have difficulty lifting their own body weight, recovering from an injury or have limited mobility. It also allows for more specific targeting of the lower body muscles without the added demand of lifting one’s own body weight.
8. Less ROM in exercise
Another significant difference between the leg press machine and squats is the range of motion (ROM) involved in each exercise. The leg press machine typically uses less ROM than squats, which can be both an advantage and a disadvantage depending on your fitness goals.
The leg press machine provides a fixed range of motion that allows for targeted work on the lower body muscles without requiring significant flexibility or mobility. The user sits in a seated position with the back supported and pushes the weight plate away from the body using the legs, typically until the legs are almost fully extended. The limited ROM means that the exercise can be performed safely and effectively even with heavy weights, making it an ideal option for individuals looking to increase their lower body strength and muscle mass.
On the other hand, squats involve a much greater ROM, requiring the lifter to lower their body weight to a full squat position before returning to a standing position. This requires a significant amount of mobility and flexibility in the hips, knees, and ankles. While squats engage multiple muscle groups, including the core and upper body muscles, the greater ROM may increase the risk of injury if proper form and technique are not maintained.
9. More coordination and technique required for squat
Squats are a compound exercise that requires more coordination and technique than the leg press machine. Unlike the leg press, squats require the use of multiple muscle groups, including the core and upper body muscles, to maintain proper form and balance throughout the exercise. This means that the technique and coordination required to perform squats correctly are more complex and challenging than the leg press.
Proper squat form requires maintaining a straight back, keeping the knees aligned with the toes, and ensuring that the weight is distributed evenly throughout the feet. This requires coordination between the legs, core, and upper body muscles to maintain proper balance and prevent injury. Additionally, the lifter must be able to control the weight during the descent and ascent phases of the exercise, further requiring coordination and technique.
The greater coordination and technique required for squats make them a more challenging exercise, but also a more effective one for overall strength and stability.
10. No heavy barbell to contend with
The leg press machine is often considered easier than squats as there is no heavy barbell to contend with during the exercise. This is because the machine provides a stable platform for the legs to push against, allowing the user to focus solely on the movement of their legs rather than the weight of a barbell.
This lack of a heavy barbell can be beneficial for individuals who are new to weightlifting or have limited mobility or injuries that make squatting with a barbell difficult. It also allows for more precise targeting of the lower body muscles without the added demand of stabilizing a heavy barbell, making it an ideal option for bodybuilders or athletes looking to increase lower body muscle mass.
While the leg press machine may be an easier and more targeted option for lower body strength training, it should not be used as a substitute for squats, which offer a wider range of benefits and overall strength and stability improvements. Incorporating both exercises into a well-rounded workout routine can provide the best results.
Related: Why Do Front Squats Hurt My Shoulders?
11. You don’t squat as much
If you find that your leg press is stronger than your squat, it is possible that you have not been training squats enough. While the leg press machine can be a useful tool for targeting the lower body muscles, it does not engage the same muscles as squats do. Squats are a compound exercise that engages multiple muscle groups, including the glutes, quads, hamstrings, and calves, as well as the core and upper body muscles. Therefore, it is important to train these muscles regularly to improve overall strength and performance.
If you have been focusing more on the leg press machine and neglecting squats, it is possible that your squat muscles have not developed enough to keep up with your leg press strength. To address this imbalance, it is recommended to incorporate squats into your workout routine, gradually increasing the weight and volume over time to build strength and improve form. Additionally, it may be helpful to work with a trainer or coach to ensure proper technique and form during squats to prevent injury and maximize results.
It is also important to consider other factors that may be contributing to the strength discrepancy, such as genetics, previous injuries, or differences in muscle fibre type. While some individuals may naturally be stronger in the leg press compared to squats, consistent training and proper form can still improve squat strength and overall lower body performance.
How much easier is leg press than squat?
Generally speaking, leg presses are often seen as an easier alternative to squats since they can be done with a seated machine and require less balance and control of your body weight. However, squats can also target additional muscle groups due to their compound movement, making them a more effective exercise if you are looking to maximize your workout. Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference and goals when deciding which one is better for you. Both exercises have benefits that can help improve overall fitness and strength, so the best way to decide between leg press and squats might be to try both and see which one works best for your body.
Why is seated leg press easier?
The seated leg press is typically easier because it allows you to enjoy a more stable and secure position while performing the exercise. When seated, your spine remains in an upright position with your glutes, core and lower back all engaged; this encourages proper form throughout each repetition. Additionally, the seat helps to reduce stress on the knees and ankles when pressing and also eliminates the need to balance. As a result, the seated leg press is an ideal exercise for those who may have limited mobility or require extra stability during their workouts. Furthermore, because the seated position limits your range of motion, it can be easier to control the weight of the load.
Is leg press easier on knees than squats?
Generally speaking, the answer is yes. Leg presses involve less weight and are better suited to protecting your knees than squats. Squats require more balance and stability which can put a strain on the knees if done incorrectly or with too much weight. Additionally, the nature of a leg press is such that it encourages correct body mechanics while squatting requires a greater degree of practice and skill. The leg press is also a much easier exercise to learn and master, which reduces the risk of injury due to improper form. Ultimately, the decision on which exercise is best for your knees should be based on comfort level and experience with each movement. If you are just starting out or have any pre-existing knee issues, the leg press may be a better option. However, if you are experienced and have good form, squats can be an effective way to work your legs. Ultimately, it is important to consult with a qualified professional before attempting any type of exercise as they will be able to give you tailored advice on which exercises are best suited for your particular needs.
Should you be able to squat the same as leg press?
Due to the difference in both exercises, it’s rare that you will be able to squat as much as you can leg press. This is because the leg press is a much more isolated exercise, meaning that it targets your quads and glutes directly. Squats, on the other hand, involve more muscle groups such as your hamstrings and core. Additionally, squats require you to use balance and stability when performing them, both of which are difficult for many people – especially those new to weightlifting. As a result, the amount of weight you can use while performing squats is usually much less than the leg press. So, even if you are able to lift the same on both exercises, it’s likely that your muscles won’t be trained in the same way due to the different muscle groups used and movements required for each exercise. Therefore, it’s important to focus on both exercises in order to get the most out of your workout and ensure that all the muscle groups are being trained effectively.
Which is harder hack squat or leg press?
Hack squats tend to be more difficult than leg presses primarily because they require more balance and stability than leg presses do. Hack squats also require you to lift the weight with your legs, while leg presses are done seated so can involve less balance and stabilization. With that being said, individuals with good balance and stability should be able to increase the weight on hack squats more quickly than leg presses. Ultimately, it is up to the individual to decide which exercise they prefer, as both exercises can yield great results while targeting similar muscles. It’s important to not just focus on one exercise and take advantage of a variety of movements in order to be successful in your workout regimen. Additionally, it is important to ensure that you perform the exercises with proper form and technique as this will reduce the risk of injury. No matter which exercise you choose, both hack squats and leg presses are great for targeting your lower body muscles.
Overall, the discrepancy between leg press strength and squat strength may be due to a variety of factors. For most individuals, it is important to consistently incorporate squats into their workout routine, as this exercise offers a range of benefits that are not available through the leg press machine. Additionally, it is important to ensure proper form and technique during the squat exercise in order to maximize results and prevent injury. With regular training and dedication, you will be able to bridge any strength discrepancies between your leg press and squat if it is substantial.
For more information on why your leg press might be stronger than your squat, as well as tips for improving squats, consult a certified personal trainer or sports medicine professional. They can provide individualised advice to help you make the most of your strength training program and reach your fitness goals.
Is your leg press much stronger than your squat and have these tips helped? Let me know in the comment section below.
If you enjoy sports and use CBD to help with your recovery in between gruelling workouts, then you are in the right place. Here at Sport CBDs, we train hard and recover the best way possible.
We have regular workouts (check out the YouTube channel), CBD news and CBD products to help you gain that edge!
If you wanted to check out the reputable CBD we have on offer here at the site, then please head to the Sport CBDs Store (CLICK HERE). We also do fitness clothing and yoga accessories too.
Until next time, all the best…
Founder – Sport CBDs
Main Image & Second Image Attribution – Image by fxquadro on Freepik